Hi Guys,
since I first got the Xantia last year and complained about the cr@ppy brakes on this forum I have known exactly what was wrong.
You see gentle stops are good, full blown crash stops are good however in every other way the brakes are worst than sh!tfull. They are the worst brakes I've ever tried to use. Gimme 2cv or Traction drum brakes anyday. At least I can regulate them with any sort of control. In the xantia this is how moderate braking. Push gently ... a little harder ... a little harder ... **** STOP YOU B@STARD followed by a full on crash stop.
What Citroen in there infinate wizdom have done is fit a spring between the brake pedal. Yes I can't believe anyone would be stupid. You see they wanted the brakes to "feel" spongy and soft like all other cars (yes after 50years of brilliant high pressure brakes the are vastly supperior to everyone elses braking system they do insane things like this).
You can simply pull the plastic spring unit out with your fingers:
If I squeeze it this is what your doing when you try and apply the cars brakes:
Fortunatly the fix really does take only 5minutes:
pull the plastic ring back:
The bit circled in yellow is the gap in the plastic split washer, now simply pull both halves this plastic off:
I went out and looked in my bucket of nuts 'n' bolts and found this metal tube. I think it's from a CX or DS somewhere, but I can't remember. All I needed to do was grind it off about 0.5mm.
Then is was a simple matter of re-assembling it.
The brakes in the Xantia are now brilliant. How much improved they are can NOT be described in words. They would be on par with early DS brakes for lightness and responsiveness. So if your not happy with your Xantias brake, the fix is extremely simple. The brakes are now absolutely bloody brilliant
seeya,
Shane L.
Terrible Xantia brakes
Moderator: RichardW
-
- Posts: 245
- Joined: 01 Apr 2003, 04:13
it looks as though you have cut the tube to the height of the spring's resting length, surely this will restrict the movement of the pedal in such a way that you can't push the pedal down far enough and thus restrict the amount of pressure you can apply to the brakes?
If this is the case surely this mod is bloody dangerous!?
If this is the case surely this mod is bloody dangerous!?
-
- Posts: 1079
- Joined: 14 Mar 2001, 01:49
The spring arrangement is what links the pedal to the button on the doseur valve. The only reason the pedal needs to be pushed down as far as it normally does is because of the spring. If the spring is replaced with a solid object then the brakes will still operate fully, just further up the pedal's travel.
-
- Posts: 1422
- Joined: 24 Jan 2002, 20:11
- x 1
This is a well known mod on the LHD XM, which also has the "silly spring". Replacement of the spring with a tube or even a 10mm nut hughly improves the braking reaction time.
I say LHD since I know that the RHD XM has a pretty weird braking arrangement, but as said, over here in Sweden it's common practice to replace the spring.
//NiSk
I say LHD since I know that the RHD XM has a pretty weird braking arrangement, but as said, over here in Sweden it's common practice to replace the spring.
//NiSk
-
- Posts: 1079
- Joined: 14 Mar 2001, 01:49
-
- Posts: 1626
- Joined: 26 Feb 2004, 23:21
-
- Posts: 462
- Joined: 19 Nov 2002, 02:42
-
- Posts: 245
- Joined: 01 Apr 2003, 04:13
-
- Posts: 622
- Joined: 22 Sep 2003, 18:06
Hi Guys,
let me explain a little better. As you all know the DS Citroens had 'button' brakes, ie: there was just a little button on the floor that looked like a dimmer switch. This was your brakes.
Would you believe that is all the brakes still are ?? You see with the GS/CX/BX/Xantia all they have done is mounted a pedal above this button that just flops around doing nothing unless you push the pedal onto the brake button.
Anyone that has driven a DS/GS/BX/CX knows they have brilliant brakes. The only difference between them and the Xantia ?? The spring tube above is mounted BETWEEN the brake pedal and brake button. Yes it appears stupidity has no bounds. Rather than apply braking force to stop the car you just compressing this stupidly dangerous spring.
So if you want your Xantia brakes to feel dramatically (infact just like DS/GS/CX/BX brakes) all you need to do is is remove the spring as described.
seeya,
Shane L.
let me explain a little better. As you all know the DS Citroens had 'button' brakes, ie: there was just a little button on the floor that looked like a dimmer switch. This was your brakes.
Would you believe that is all the brakes still are ?? You see with the GS/CX/BX/Xantia all they have done is mounted a pedal above this button that just flops around doing nothing unless you push the pedal onto the brake button.
Anyone that has driven a DS/GS/BX/CX knows they have brilliant brakes. The only difference between them and the Xantia ?? The spring tube above is mounted BETWEEN the brake pedal and brake button. Yes it appears stupidity has no bounds. Rather than apply braking force to stop the car you just compressing this stupidly dangerous spring.
So if you want your Xantia brakes to feel dramatically (infact just like DS/GS/CX/BX brakes) all you need to do is is remove the spring as described.
seeya,
Shane L.
-
- Posts: 23
- Joined: 25 Jan 2004, 01:52
My xantia brake pedal sits very low in relation to the accelerator and clutch pedals. Brakes seem OK, and have recently replaced front and rear discs and pads and bled brakes, but cannot get the brake pedal up any higher.Do you think it would be ok to replace the plastic spring unit with a slightly longer metal spacer.
-
- Posts: 1079
- Joined: 14 Mar 2001, 01:49
-
- Posts: 360
- Joined: 12 Apr 2004, 00:43
-
- Posts: 121
- Joined: 06 Jun 2004, 22:31
- x 3
I tried this yesterday, and it really is that easy. It took a minute or two to dislodge the assembly with my fingers, but no tools were required.
For a spring replacement, I used a stack of washers (12mm ID, 22mm OD, 4mm thick). These were actually Jaguar V12 head stud washers.
Note that the pictures do not show that there is a rubber spring inside the steel spring. This is why you need to use tubing or washers and not a solid rod.
With the tubing/washers in place the inner rubber spring will have no effect. I do wonder if this is asking for trouble, as the rubber spring is designed to take the force of emergency braking, and the parts the steel spring rest on are not.
Regarding the effectiveness of this modification, I think it depends on your driving style. I don't really notice much difference, as the same force on the pedal still produces the same braking force. The pedal movement is less.
For a spring replacement, I used a stack of washers (12mm ID, 22mm OD, 4mm thick). These were actually Jaguar V12 head stud washers.
Note that the pictures do not show that there is a rubber spring inside the steel spring. This is why you need to use tubing or washers and not a solid rod.
With the tubing/washers in place the inner rubber spring will have no effect. I do wonder if this is asking for trouble, as the rubber spring is designed to take the force of emergency braking, and the parts the steel spring rest on are not.
Regarding the effectiveness of this modification, I think it depends on your driving style. I don't really notice much difference, as the same force on the pedal still produces the same braking force. The pedal movement is less.
-
- Posts: 6060
- Joined: 21 Feb 2003, 04:56
- x 1
Earlier models (GS/CX/BX) uses the exacty same type brake doseur valve - with no rubber or steel spring between pedal and the doseur valve rubber button.
There are no reports on damaged doseur valve units on these models because of emergency braking.
The reason why this subject may confuse many Xantia owners is, that they have not tried how exact the same brakes system works in a BX or CX.
The usual brake pedal travel on any standard car is approx 100mm.
On a BX/CX you have approx 20mm.
Admittently this gives quite a few screaming brake actions for the first timer. But it is amazing how fast you adapt to this - and enjoy a very safe feeling with the brakes.
There are no reports on damaged doseur valve units on these models because of emergency braking.
The reason why this subject may confuse many Xantia owners is, that they have not tried how exact the same brakes system works in a BX or CX.
The usual brake pedal travel on any standard car is approx 100mm.
On a BX/CX you have approx 20mm.
Admittently this gives quite a few screaming brake actions for the first timer. But it is amazing how fast you adapt to this - and enjoy a very safe feeling with the brakes.
-
- Posts: 622
- Joined: 22 Sep 2003, 18:06
<blockquote id="quote"><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica" id="quote">quote:<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"><i>Originally posted by xantiav6</i>
I tried this yesterday, and it really is that easy. It took a minute or two to dislodge the assembly with my fingers, but no tools were required.
For a spring replacement, I used a stack of washers (12mm ID, 22mm OD, 4mm thick). These were actually Jaguar V12 head stud washers.
Note that the pictures do not show that there is a rubber spring inside the steel spring. This is why you need to use tubing or washers and not a solid rod.
With the tubing/washers in place the inner rubber spring will have no effect. I do wonder if this is asking for trouble, as the rubber spring is designed to take the force of emergency braking, and the parts the steel spring rest on are not.
Regarding the effectiveness of this modification, I think it depends on your driving style. I don't really notice much difference, as the same force on the pedal still produces the same braking force. The pedal movement is less.
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></blockquote id="quote"></font id="quote">
It makes me wonder if they didn't have different grades of springs. Maybe some were stronger. The difference with my car was dramatic, possibly your car had a MUCH stronger spring so the difference isn't as noticable.
seeya,
Shane L.
I tried this yesterday, and it really is that easy. It took a minute or two to dislodge the assembly with my fingers, but no tools were required.
For a spring replacement, I used a stack of washers (12mm ID, 22mm OD, 4mm thick). These were actually Jaguar V12 head stud washers.
Note that the pictures do not show that there is a rubber spring inside the steel spring. This is why you need to use tubing or washers and not a solid rod.
With the tubing/washers in place the inner rubber spring will have no effect. I do wonder if this is asking for trouble, as the rubber spring is designed to take the force of emergency braking, and the parts the steel spring rest on are not.
Regarding the effectiveness of this modification, I think it depends on your driving style. I don't really notice much difference, as the same force on the pedal still produces the same braking force. The pedal movement is less.
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></blockquote id="quote"></font id="quote">
It makes me wonder if they didn't have different grades of springs. Maybe some were stronger. The difference with my car was dramatic, possibly your car had a MUCH stronger spring so the difference isn't as noticable.
seeya,
Shane L.